top of page

Villain or Victim? A historical fiction character divided

Oct 15
6 min read

Turning real-life records into a historical fiction character.


A kind face, his daughter’s death certificate, a host of machine patents and a few notes from my father, were all I had to base my historical family saga character on.


William Seller seemed thoughtful, dignified, grieving, intelligent and enterprising. He also had a mind of his own when it came to creating his character.


WARNING: contains spoilers if you haven't read A Legacy Forged or Angelina.


William Seller, a Victorian businessman with grey hair and full set of grew whiskers. He wears a pair of wire-rimmed spectacles and has a dignified and kind expression.

The Real William or an Author’s Interpretation?


In spite of my intention to create a kind and thoughtful character, William insisted on appearing to be thought-less, not thought-full. In A Legacy Forged, at just fifteen, he held the family together when a newborn sibling died. As a father, he steered everyone through the loss of his five-year-old daughter, Alice, comforting his mother, who had nursed her, and supporting his pregnant wife, Elizabeth. Yet when Nellie was born so soon after, William’s heart seemed to stick. A daughter. The third daughter. Not a son to inherit the business. Nellie would yearn for her father’s attention for most of her life.

I look at William’s picture and feel such love for his gentle, dignified face. Looking heartless was never my intention for him. But he kept rewriting himself.


A Father’s Shadow


William was the first son of dynamic, driven, self-starter Matthew Seller, who built a business in Industrial Revolution Birmingham through sheer determination and courage. Matthew ran away from home at ten to escape a father whose violence was fuelled by drink. He escaped the violence, but the anger came with him. He tried so hard not to become his father, yet he never learned to manage his own frustration. It brewed until it spewed out of the cracks, and it was William who suffered it. Did William pass the anger on? No, he internalised it.


“I never felt good enough, you know, Elizabeth.”

When Matthew told him to get rid of the rifling machine, William did, just not the way his father had instructed. He sold it whole to Finn Cahill and pocketed the cash for his “getting married fund.” When Matthew discovered the machine was arming the Irish nationalist cause, his disappointment was crushing.


“How can you be so disconnected from the world around you, William?”

But, was Matthew proud of his son? You bet he was. Did he ever say so? Heavens, no! Victorian men kept feelings under tight wraps. What a suppressed time to live in. William learned to work around his father, finding ways to get what he wanted while letting Matthew think it was his idea. That’s a habit worth remembering.


Florrie, and the Women Who Held Him Together


William showed some peculiar contradictions. In Angelina, on his wedding night, of all times, he gently blesses Florrie’s cooling body:


“Bless the eyes that watched me grow up.”

As a boy, Florrie was the one he ran to when his father was too harsh. They shared a “secret language”. But as his attention turned to the business, that tenderness became diluted. Women began to matter less as men became the custodians of all things business. When Elizabeth told him he undervalued his mother’s part in Seller & Son, her words “sunk into the dark recesses of William’s mind”, and there they stayed. Did you notice that shift as you read A Legacy Forged? It's worth noting that the shifts made in the trilogy are all subtle, they're there for a reason. They demonstrate how negative behaviours become normalised until cold realisation shows them for what they are.


Three Perspectives


The decision that got everyone’s goat was Angelina’s fate at the end of both books. Once again, the failure to communicate rings a familiar bell. In Angelina, William did explain himself, just to the wrong person. Upstairs, away from his father’s body, he set out his reasons to Albert, who challenged him:


“But not the spirit of the will.” Said Albert.

Yet Albert listened, and came round. He saw the business sense despite his love for Angelina. He also saw that he'd have to take some responsibility himself if he went against his father's wishes. Meanwhile Angelina, sitting beneath the open window, heard every word. Why not say it to her face? Why not ask what she wanted, and map out the options together with Elizabeth and Albert?


The Case Against William


Let’s be fair to Angelina first. William’s distrust didn’t begin with the laudanum. Ever since the trouble in town with the Irish, he’d been short with her. When his mother died, he assumed the worst. When his father died, he gave Angelina two days to leave the home she’d kept for fourteen years. Even when he sensed he’d mishandled it, he didn’t put it right: pressing on ignoring it. Is that a familiar story?


That old habit of convenient workarounds was at play, too. He’d stretched the truth to Finn, pocketed the cash and, “with his calm eloquence”, won the argument over the share deal while his mother was ignored. Now he kept to the letter of the will, not the spirit. And Angelina’s fourteen years of caring for both his parents? That was the same unseen women’s work he’d overlooked in Sarah; you'll see it repeated in A Legacy At War. To William, it was a transaction. It was prejudice — of its time, but prejudice all the same. Victorian man or not, that hurts.


In William’s Defence


I actually like William, so I feel bound to defend him.


He was a good son. Through his father’s long decline he visited every week with a bottle of whiskey and kept Matthew included in the business long after it stopped making sense to him. He and Angelina had even been allies, together easing Matthew into retirement to make way for Albert. The rift came from grief and suspicion, not lifelong dislike.


And his suspicion wasn’t baseless. Something did happen at his mother’s deathbed, and nobody told him. Sarah and Matthew never sat him down and explained. It was their business, so why should they? Because it would have avoided all the nonsense afterwards. William was right that something was wrong. He was just wrong about why.


Then there’s the timing. He did all this on the morning his father died, overwhelmed and wanting to “move on quickly”. As executor, he had a duty to his siblings as shareholders. The company had helped fund the house, and a rent-free property didn’t make business sense to 1896 William. What if, as he told Albert, Angelina’s family moved in? Who would manage that? With anti-Irish feeling still raw after the Murphy Riots you’ll read about in Angelina, image mattered to a respectable family business.


Beneath it all was a kindness, of sorts. William pictured Angelina alone in that house after a lifetime surrounded by people. With her son, at least, she would be cared for.


Angelina Has the Last Word


As I wrote the chapter in Angelina, after Matthew’s funeral, Angelina took over the writing. She came home to her son, drained of emotion. Her daughter-in-law looked after her, and her small great-grandson climbed onto her lap for a cuddle. Had she stayed in the home she’d shared with Matthew, she would have laid the fire herself, made a meal for herself, or not, and sat in the silence of her own company. That felt too sad to write. It was Angelina herself who said:


“I think William was right.”

The Future for William


William’s story continues in A Legacy at War. Once again, I’m trying to show his kind side, but he persists in being an old-school Victorian man, underplaying every small act of love I give him. And here’s the irony: he heeded Angelina’s warning about the MacCarthys even as he pushed her away. His distrust may cost him the one person who watched his back.


What can an author do when a character is determined to write himself?


Have you read A Legacy Forged and Angelina? Put your Victorian head on. What would you have done had you been William? Would your decision be based on 2026 or 1896?


If you enjoy my character dissections or love character-driven historical fiction consider subscribing for my newsletters or follow me on social media, those links are at the bottom of each website page.

1 Comment


Ooo, I love how William has written himself! What a wonderful way for you to write - you are connected with your characters on so many levels which makes for wonderful stories. I suppose we are all a complex, sometimes chaotic, mix of goodness, blind spots, practicalities and, well, badness for want of a better word. But some are truly bad in contrast to those who don't set out to do things which might be bad for others.....

Like
bottom of page